The 12 Best Cruz Bay Homes For Sale Under $1 Million

Cruz Bay is one of the most desirable areas on the island of St. John, so its no wonder prices can be high. But, you can find several gems in Cruz Bay at a reasonable price. Here are the 12 best Cruz Bay homes for sale under $1 million.

Odessa $920,000


Odessa is truly beachfront living! 63 steps down separate you from the parking, but once there you have an amazing 2,000 square feet of deck with a pool and hot tub! This 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom home has a quaint cottage feel on one of the favorite bays in Cruz Bay – Chocolate Hole.

62A Chocolate Hole $898,000

62A Chocolate Hole

Extraordinary value radiates from this attractive masonry residence in Estate Chocolate Hole. Designed by local architect, Rob Crane, there are many custom touches in this charming Caribbean style home including West Indian columns and archways. Featuring French clay roof tiles, poured concrete construction, beautiful native stonework, a circular driveway, spacious covered outdoor gallery, upscale bronze railings, stone staircase entry, vaulted ceilings, a tasteful lower two bedroom apartment, great views of Chocolate Hole, southeasterly exposure to catch the cool tradewinds, and professional landscaping.

CB Gift & Regenback $895,000

CB Gift & Regenback

This three bedroom, 2 bath home located in the Gift & Regenback estate has over 2,000 square feet of living space and a fenced in area for pets.

477 E Chocolate Hole $890,000

477 E Chocolate Hole

With 3,300 sq ft  split equally between indoor and outdoor space, this 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom home makes a perfect rental. The great room is separated from the bedrooms by a patio and boasts beautiful ceilings throughout.

H1 & H2 Gift & Regenback $849,000

H1 & H2 Gift & Regenback

This Cruz Bay villa boasts 3 beds and 3 baths complete with two outside showers, features a lap pool, tons of deck space and an outside blender-ready pool deck bar.

Skylark $820,000


Income producing investment property with lots of potential and multiple use-age possibilities. Great opportunity to live in one apartment and rent the rest. All masonry with beautiful stone walls. On property parking for 3 – 4 jeeps. Adjacent parcel with cottage and wood shop potentially for sale as well. All units come furnished, ready to move in. Property grosses $5200 a month as is Middle units which are now one bedroom units can be easily reconfigured to go back together as a 2 bedroom / 2 bath full apartment. Some tree topping and trimming would open up the pie shaped view of the Caribbean.

1-2-3 Grunwald $799,000

1-2-3 Grunwald

Skylark is an extremely well built, two unit, income producing home with incredible sunset views of St. Thomas and outer cays. Quiet neighborhood, close to town, easily converts into a short term rental (ample room for pool and spa). Rolling hurricane shutters, custom mahogany doors and trim. Custom Kitchen, cedar closets and solar hot water. Spacious 725 sq/ft loft. Beautiful island stonework.


482 B Chocolate Hole $749,000

482 B Chocolate Hole

This charming 5 bedroom, Caribbean style home features a very private & sunny pool plus decks in a quiet, breezey location in Chocolate Hole convenient to Cruz Bay’s shops and restaurants. Beautifully finished Brazilian hardwood home with native stonework arched entry, 2 island stone showers, classic mahogany floors, A/C in all bedrooms, and inside-outside tropical living in common areas.

8 B Enighed $695,000

8 B Enighed

Lovely island cottage only 5 minutes drive to town with breathtaking views of St. Thomas and sunset! Enjoy as first home ownership or income producing rental villa. 2 level home with separate entrance to second bedroom. Large storage space and 2 car park. Room for expansion or pool. Quiet neighborhood!

Eleahas Garden $669,000

eleahas garden

Eleah’s Garden is a well-built and lovingly maintained home with ocean views across the south side. A charming 4 bedroom, 3 bath main house rented out on a short term basis; the lower level care takers cottage is the perfect spot for a owner or income producing longer term rental. Eleah’s Garden is a perfect family home with interior access to the bedrooms and gentle yard to play or garden! Centrally located off the Gift Hill Road, a short walk to nearby school, a short drive to Cruz Bay or the beaches.

1- E Gift & Regenback $575,000

1- E Gift & Regenback

Wonderful investment property or family home currently with 3 income producing units grossing $2900.00 a month. Close to town but quiet end of the road location.Water views of Pillsbury Sound, St Thomas and the out lying cays.Sunset views. Multiple large outside decks and interior stonewalls are just some of the properties features. Fully hurricane shuttered.

9-19 Rem Glucksberg $359,000

9-19 Rem Glucksberg


It is possible to find an affordable island home in St John for under a million dollars. Just visit any of these retreats to be surprised by the space and amenities.