The Best St John Cottages Under $500K

Find your St. John dream cottage for under $500K. You will not be restricted to any certain area or home size with this budget, as there are so many cottages to choose from.

Coral Bay ($250,000)

Coral Bay cottage

6-3-22-J Carolina holds a 2009 built 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom home that has been very well kept. 554 square feet make up this well shaded home near Coral Bay. The .539 acre lot has room for the homeowner to expand the home or even add a pool if desired. Utilizing the hillside as an aid in landscaping, stone terraces marry into the naturally beautiful scenery. This slice of paradise is surrounded by tall shade trees and a mountain view.

Tree-Top Hideaway ($299,999)

Carolina Cottage

9-9-5 Carolina is where you can find a home that was built in 2013 that boasts 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, set inside of 2,040 square feet. Sitting on a half-acre of property are 3 separate living areas—the first has 2 bedrooms and one bathroom and a hot tub, while the remaining two living areas each have a single bedroom and bathroom with their own kitchens and decks that are prefect to enjoy the view of the majestic valley. This home is accessed via a dirt road with a steep to moderate grade.

Glucksberg Cottage ($359,000)

St John Cottage

4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms make up this 1399 square foot home found at 9-19 Rem Glucksberg. The 1987 treasure sits on one half acre of lush land, with two bedrooms and one bathroom on each level. There is a modest freshwater stream on the property—combined with the cool tropical breeze, this makes for the perfect garden space. Each bedroom is outfitted with a window air conditioning unit, providing maximum comfort.

Coral Bay ($398,999)

Coral Bay Cottage 398K

6-2-2-B Carolina in Coral Bay is where you will find the epitome of a Caribbean cottage. The 1 bedroom 1 bathroom home is a generous 1,300 square feet that is protected by a gated driveway. From the home, there are outstanding views of Great Coral Harbor and a view of the rest of the property that is large enough to build another home onto. Built in 2007, this cottage comes straight from a dream.

Bay Tree Cottages ($450,000)

Bay Tree Cottages

Surrounded by abundant bay rum trees and the breathtaking view of Bordeaux Mountain, this home has a total of 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, and both and upper and lower deck. The main home has one bedroom and one bathroom while the caretaker’s cottage is a modest 512 square feet, single bedroom and bathroom. Upstairs in the main home there is a laundry area and great room, while everything else is downstairs—including an ensuite bathroom. This dream home is located at 10-49 Carolina.

Kokomo Cottage ($499,000)

Coral Bay Cottage Near Water

Built in 1998, this single bedroom and bathroom cottage is a traditional West Indian villa contained in 660 square feet. 8-4-10-B Carolina is where you will find not only this stunning home, but also priceless panoramic views. The property is located centrally to all of the attractions that are loved on the island, but also boasts a sizable deck that is perfect for dining and lounging at home. On the outside, the home is on half of an acre surrounded by forest, while the inside is adorned with the previous owner’s own décor.

Carolina Cottage $499,000)

Carolina Cottage

1,563 square feet, 2 bedrooms, and one bathroom make up this perfect home. An open great room, cathedral ceilings, and double doors that lead to a sprawling deck are just a few of the best features. The home has views of East End, Hurricane Hole, Coral Harbor, and Caribbean. Built in 1996, 1-31 Carolina couldn’t be much more perfect. A paved concrete driveway points to a large parking area for the home. There is a laundry room along with a deck in the lower area of the home, and new decking for the upper portion.

Take your pick from any of these homes, there is something that would satisfy anyone in both price and size. Make your dream a reality!